The case for change
Why we are changing
The world the RSA was built for no longer exists. Staying the course means slow decline. This page explains why, and why our new strategy is the answer.
Where we began
Founded for veterans, by veterans
The RSA was founded on 28 April 1916 by wounded men back from Gallipoli. They set out to welcome, care for and speak up for returning soldiers, and to honour the dead. Pensions, land for returned men, Poppy Day and the Anzac Day public holiday all grew from that work.
Avondale’s RSA began in 1933, in the Depression, started by local First World War veterans. Its first home on Layard Street was a gift: in 1937–38 Albert Crum gave his tuck shop in memory of his son Fred, who was killed in 1917. Avondale was a dry suburb, so the club existed for welfare, comradeship and remembrance, not for a bar.
Running a licensed club was only ever a power the RSA could use. It was a means, never the purpose.
Built for another time
A model that worked, for a population that has changed
The model worked while almost every family was tied to service. National membership peaked at 136,000 after the Second World War. It relied on four things.
A large local veteran population
A volunteer women’s section
Carrying welfare, catering and visits.
A club-centred drinking culture
Few other places to gather
All four have faded.
Hospitality grew out of what veterans did together, and by the 1970s it carried the club. Avondale had more than 700 members in 1974 and over 2,300 by 2009. But membership opened to the wider community, and by 2020 only 15% of members were Returned or Service members.
Each new income source, first housie, then the bar, then gaming machines, became the thing to protect. By 1991 the machines brought in about two-thirds of the club’s income.
What has changed
Six shifts, and how the strategy answers each
Each change was real. Each was read as a trading problem. The strategy treats them for what they are.
| The issue | What it means | The strategy’s answer |
|---|---|---|
| Veterans have changed | About 44,000 veterans live in New Zealand, from many eras, ages and places. Support is fragmented and slow, and claims can take close to a year. An estimated fewer than 1 in 20 contemporary veterans use government support or mainstream charities, the RSA included. | Veteran support and advocacy. Dedicated capacity, clear pathways to help, and a voice at District and National level. |
| Members have changed | Membership is down 55% since 2019–20. Only 13% of members are Returned or Service members, and the median age is 75. | Belonging and membership. Rebuild around veterans of every era, with one verified membership list and regular contact. |
| Hospitality has changed | New Zealanders are drinking at record lows and have many more places to go. An RSA no longer draws custom just for being an RSA. | A professional operator runs hospitality and carries its risk, so we keep a place to belong without the trading risk. |
| Gaming has gone | The machines were under regulatory pressure and were switched off in January 2026, with the licence surrendered. They cannot come back. | Financial sustainability. Income from more than one source, and never again a single golden ticket. |
| Avondale has changed | Avondale is young and diverse: 26% Pasifika, 38% Asian, 47% born overseas, and only 11% aged 65 or over. | Belonging. Connect the community to veterans, through schools, cadets, youth groups and community organisations. |
| Direction and oversight were missing | No strategic plan or annual budget was ever adopted. Membership records sat in 22 spreadsheets, and advice and warnings were not acted on. | A lean organisation with a plan, a budget, monthly reporting and one verified membership database. |
What was tried
The same answer, again and again
For sixty years the club read every change as a trading problem and answered with more of the same.
Housie, then the bar, then machines became the thing to protect. Each was backed by bigger buildings and more borrowing.
The warnings arrived. A loss in 2007 and a difficult AGM, where members named the changes. The response was more machines, more property and appeals to spend more.
Layard Street was sold, when the club was losing about $2,000 a week. The sale cleared all debt and was meant to buy time to restructure. The restructure was cost cutting.
The move to 48 Rosebank Road was built around keeping a gaming licence. What veterans needed from a home was never the question, and the same model was rebuilt.
Losses grew. In FY2026 the club spent $47,608 on entertainment and $3,220 on Anzac and remembrance. In January 2026 the machines were switched off.
Where that left us
Where we are now
55%
fall in membership since 2019–20
13%
of members are Returned or Service members
75
median age of members whose age is on record
$2.4m
fall in the club’s net worth since 2019
The club has lost money every year since FY2022, while almost nothing was spent on veterans. In FY2026 it held one Anzac or remembrance event.
The club has no debt, and a base to rebuild from. The question is what to build.
What the record shows
Two failures, one cause
The club lost its purpose
Each income source became the thing to protect. By 2015 the question was how to keep the pokies, not why the RSA exists. The club became a hospitality venue with a veteran association attached.
The club had no direction
No plan, no right people and no checking of results. A commercial operation was run by volunteers, without the expertise it needed.
Both came from misreading the landscape, and answering every change as a trading problem.
The answer
A strategy built for the world as it is
The strategy does not try to win back the old model. It returns to our purpose and builds a structure to deliver it.
Purpose first
Veterans and their families, remembrance, and a place to belong. Every decision is tested against it.
Four focus areas
Veteran support and advocacy. Remembrance. Belonging and membership. Financial sustainability.
A lean structure with expertise
A professional operator carries the trading risk. Commercial and community are kept apart. And we are held to account with a plan, a budget and regular reporting.
The purpose has not changed. The model has.